Can Modern Smartphones Be Repaired and To What Extent? This Study Says It All

can-modern-smartphones-be-repaired-and-to-what-extent?-this-study-says-it-all
Can Modern Smartphones Be Repaired and To What Extent? This Study Says It All

New research is shedding light on modern smartphone designs and their ability to be repaired.

Before modern smartphones came into existence, many manufacturers allowed owners to replace batteries by themselves. But as days go by, the designs and interfaces of smartphones are getting more complex, thanks for business monopolies and planned obsolescence.

This is why tech giants such as Apple are going out of their to explain to users that you can no longer repair your device alone at home safely. It requires experts to analyze the situation and offer replacements when a switch is needed. Other than tools, a lot of repairs need third-party tools to get the job done right.

As per one device repairing platform, iFixit, modern devices make use of specific materials like strong glue and screws. This is why tech giants Apple and Samsung rank pretty low in terms of the repairability factor. Shockingly, iFixit experts in their index gave Pixel 8 and 8 Pro scores of six out of 10.

The score comes after looking at several factors. For instance, how readily available documents are for a repair and if any parts are needed that cannot be found easily. Is the battery glued in areas that can be reached easily? Do you need an expert’s help to unscrew the device to access a certain site on the device?

There are a lot of questions to answer and based on how well a device answers them, the better their ranking on repairability indexes. You’ll be amazed to learn how the Samsung Galaxy device received just a score of four out of 10. But it was praised for using normal screws from Phillips.

When you take a look at iPhone devices, they also got a low score of just four out of 10. Still, iFixit says the latest range of iOS phones ranks high in terms of easy battery replacements. The same goes for the screen that can be replaced swiftly.

In terms of spare parts, Apple loses out. The pairing of parts is complex with iPhones as each part is paired against a digital serial number. Hence, you can’t land up at any repair shop but a specific software one to get the job done. This means repairability gets more challenging.

Repairability Ratings for Smartphones (10=highest)

OEM Device Date Score**
HMD Skyline 2024 9
Fairphone 5 2023 10
Nokia G22 2023 8
Google Pixel 8 2023 6
Google Pixel 8 Pro 2023 6
Apple iPhone 15* 2023 4
Apple iPhone 15 Plus* 2023 4
Apple iPhone 15 Pro* 2023 4
Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max* 2023 4
Google Pixel 7a 2023 4
Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra* 2023 4
Google Pixel Fold 2023 3
Apple iPhone 14 Plus* 2022 7
Apple iPhone 14 Pro* 2022 6
Apple iPhone 14 Pro Max* 2022 6
Google Pixel 7 2022 5
Google Pixel 7 Pro 2022 5
Google Pixel 6a 2022 5
Apple iPhone 14 2022 4
Samsung Galaxy S22 2022 3
Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra 2022 3
Fairphone 4 2021 10
Apple iPhone 13 Pro 2021 6
Google Pixel 6 2021 6
Google Pixel 5a 2021 6
Google Pixel 6 Pro 2021 5
Mi 11 2021 4
Apple iPhone 12 Pro Max 2020 6
Apple iPhone 12 mini 2020 6
Apple iPhone 12 Pro 2020 6
Google Pixel 5 2020 6
Google Pixel 4a 2020 6
Apple iPhone SE 2020 2020 6
Huawei Mate 40 Pro 2020 4
Samsung Galaxy A51 2020 4
Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra 2020 3
Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra 2020 3
Microsoft Surface Duo 2020 2
Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 2020 2
Motorola razr 2020 1
Fairphone 3 2019 10
Shift 6m 2019 9
Apple iPhone 11 2019 6
Apple iPhone 11 Pro Max 2019 6
Google Pixel 3a 2019 6
Google Pixel 3a XL 2019 6
Google Pixel 4 XL 2019 4
Huawei Mate 20 X 5G 2019 4
Samsung Galaxy Note10 Plus 5G 2019 3
Samsung Galaxy S10 2019 3
Samsung Galaxy Fold 2019 2
Nokia 8110 4G 2018 8
Apple iPhone XR 2018 6
Apple iPhone XS 2018 6
OnePlus 6 2018 5
Huawei Mate 20 Pro 2018 4
Google Pixel 3 XL 2018 4
Google Pixel 3 2018 4
LG G7 Thin Q 2018 4
Huawei P20 Pro 2018 4
Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus 2018 4
Samsung Galaxy S9 2018 4
OnePlus 5 2017 7
Apple iPhone X 2017 6
Google Pixel 2 XL 2017 6
Google Pixel 2 2017 6
Apple iPhone 8 2017 6
Apple iPhone 8 Plus 2017 6
LG G6 2017 5
Huawei Mate 10 Pro 2017 4
Samsung Galaxy Note8 2017 4
Samsung Galaxy Note Fan Edition 2017 4
Samsung Galaxy S8 Plus 2017 4
Samsung Galaxy S8 2017 4
Essential Phone 2017 1
LG G5 2016 8
Google Pixel XL 2016 7
Google Pixel 2016 7
Apple iPhone 7 2016 7
Apple iPhone 7 Plus 2016 7
Moto Z 2016 7
Meizu MX6 2016 7
Vivo X7 Plus 2016 7
Huawei P9 2016 7
Oppo R9m 2016 7
Sony Xperia X Compact 2016 6
Asus Zenfone 3 Max 2016 6
Vivo X7 2016 6
Xiaomi Mi 5 2016 6
Apple iPhone SE 2016 6
Huawei Mate 9 2016 5
Samsung Galaxy Note7 2016 4
Samsung Galaxy S7 2016 3
Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge 2016 3
Fairphone 2 2015 10
Xiaomi Redmi Note 3 2015 8
LG G4 2015 8
Wiko Pulp 4G Phone 2015 7
Apple iPhone 6s 2015 7
Apple iPhone 6s Plus 2015 7
Nexus 5X 2015 7
OnePlus 2 2015 7
Lenovo K5 Note 2015 6
Huawei Mate 8 2015 6
Shift 5.1 2015 6
Samsung Galaxy S6 2015 4
Samsung Galaxy S6 Edge 2015 3
Nexus 6P 2015 2
HTC One M9 2015 2
Nexus 6 2014 7
Apple iPhone 6 Plus 2014 7
Apple iPhone 6 2014 7
Samsung Galaxy Alpha 2014 5
Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini 2014 5
OnePlus One 2014 5
Samsung Galaxy S5 2014 5
Amazon Fire Phone 2014 3
HTC One M8 2014 2
Nexus 5 2013 8
Samsung Galaxy S4 2013 8
BlackBerry Z10 2013 8
Fairphone 1 2013 7
Motorola Moto X 1st Generation 2013 7
Apple iPhone 5c 2013 6
Apple iPhone 5s 2013 6
HTC One 2013 1
Samsung Galaxy Note II 2012 8
Samsung Galaxy S III 2012 8
Nexus 4 2012 7
Apple iPhone 5 2012 7
Motorola Droid 4 2012 4
Motorola Droid Bionic 2011 9
Motorola Atrix 4G 2011 9
Samsung Galaxy Note 2011 8
Samsung Galaxy S II 2011 8
Samsung Galaxy Nexus 2011 7
Apple iPhone 4S 2011 6
Motorola Droid 3 2011 6
Samsung Galaxy S 4G 2011 6
Apple iPhone 4 Verizon 2011 6
Motorola Droid RAZR 2011 4
Nokia N8 2010 8
Nexus S 2010 7
HTC Surround 2010 5
Apple iPhone 3GS 2009 7
Apple iPhone 3G 2008 7
Apple iPhone (1st Generation) 2007 2
* Provisional
** 10 = Best

The score factors in 10% for the service manual, 10% for replacement parts, and 80% for the ease and time required to replace the most critical components.

Read next:

• How We Can Save The Environment by Extending The Smartphone Lifetime